In-depth review
Investment Rarities Review (2026)
Investment Rarities is best for gold and silver investors who value personal guidance, insured delivery, and segregated Brink’s storage from a dealer operating since 1973.
3.8
Our score / 5
Founded
1973
Metals offered
Gold, Silver, and Platinum
Storage
Brink’s
BBB rating
A+
The quick verdict
Is Investment Rarities worth it?
Investment Rarities is worth considering if you want an experienced, silver-focused dealer with personal broker assistance and access to GoldStar Trust for a self-directed IRA. Its operating history, A+ BBB rating, and fully allocated Brink’s storage are strengths, but limited pricing transparency, a narrower IRA catalog, and sparse independent feedback require additional comparison shopping.
Bottom line
Best for investors seeking silver or gold with personal assistance and segregated storage. Consider alternatives if you want transparent online prices, all four IRA-approved metals, or a fully published fee schedule.
What we like
Watch out for
Best for
Not ideal for
Costs
Fees, pricing & minimums
Investment Rarities says it assists customers investing amounts ranging from $500 to $500,000, indicating that smaller purchases are accepted. However, it does not publish one universal minimum for all cash purchases, storage accounts, or precious-metals IRAs. Product-level minimum quantities may apply, particularly to silver bags and large bullion bars.
Pricing is primarily quote-based. The company states that it offers competitive pricing without hidden fees, but public product pages do not provide a complete live-price catalog showing dealer premiums or buyback spreads. Customers should request an itemized confirmation showing the spot price, premium, payment charge, shipping or storage expense, and current liquidation bid.
GoldStar Trust Company is linked as the IRA custodian, but Investment Rarities does not publish GoldStar’s current setup, administration, transaction, and depository charges. These should be confirmed directly from the custodian’s current fee schedule. Promotions, free publications, and other offers may change over time
Security
Storage & custody
Investment Rarities offers storage through Brink’s under an agreement between the customer and the storage provider. The company states that each customer’s name is attached to the exact silver purchased, the metal is not commingled or leased, and customers may sell it, arrange delivery, or collect it according to the storage agreement. The arrangement is represented as insured.
For precious-metals IRAs, Investment Rarities directs prospective customers to GoldStar Trust Company. GoldStar’s available depositories include Delaware Depository, IDS of Delaware, Texas Precious Metals Depository, and A-M Global Logistics, with commingled or segregated storage options depending on the facility and metal. The actual depository must be selected through the custodial documents.
Non-IRA metals may be delivered to the customer or stored privately. IRA-owned metals must remain with the custodian’s approved depository; keeping IRA metals at home or in a personal safe-deposit box can be treated as a taxable distribution.
Products
Metals & product selection
Investment Rarities primarily specializes in physical gold and silver. Its catalog emphasizes 100-ounce silver bars, pre-1965 U.S. silver coin bags, American Gold Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, Austrian Philharmonics, South African Krugerrands, and historic U.S. Double Eagles. Selected platinum products may also be available, but platinum and palladium are not presented as core offerings.
The company supports eligible gold and silver purchases through self-directed IRAs. Its focus on recognizable bullion products can make comparison and resale more straightforward, although customers should distinguish between bullion and numismatic coins. Historic or collectible coins can carry substantially higher premiums and may not qualify for an IRA.
Trust
Reputation & track record
Investment Rarities was founded by Jim Cook in 1973. The company reports completing approximately 400,000 transactions for 250,000 customers and selling and delivering more than $3 billion in precious metals. These figures are company-reported and have not been independently audited for this review.
The BBB lists Investment Rarities as accredited, with an A+ rating and more than 50 years in business. However, public review volume is very small. The BBB review page displayed one critical customer review concerning the authenticity of an old silver purchase; Investment Rarities disputed the allegation, noted that it could not verify the original transaction, and offered to consider a compromise. A single disputed review is not enough to establish a broader service pattern, but buyers should inspect orders promptly and retain all invoices and assay documentation.
No material provider-specific regulatory enforcement action was identified in the authoritative sources reviewed for this article.
Scorecard
How we scored Investment Rarities
Not sure Investment Rarities is the right fit?
See how it stacks up against every provider we rate.
Editorial
How we review gold IRA companies
We evaluate gold IRA companies across fees and value, product selection, storage and security, customer support, and reputation. Published costs, dealer spreads, compliant custody, insurance, product liquidity, operating history, complaint patterns, and the quality of customer disclosures receive the greatest weight. Company claims are compared with independent records and current custodian or depository information whenever possible.
FAQ
Common questions about Investment Rarities
What is Investment Rarities’ minimum investment?
Investment Rarities does not publish one universal minimum for every purchase or IRA. The company says it assists customers investing from approximately $500 to $500,000, but product quantities, storage requirements, and IRA rules may result in different minimums. Confirm the applicable amount before opening an account.
Is Investment Rarities a legitimate, safe choice?
Investment Rarities is an established precious-metals dealer founded in 1973, with BBB accreditation and an A+ rating. It offers insured delivery and segregated storage through Brink’s. Investors should nevertheless obtain written pricing, verify the products received, retain transaction records, and independently review the custodian and depository agreements.
Can I roll over a 401(k) into a gold IRA with them?
Investment Rarities can help eligible customers purchase gold or silver through a self-directed IRA administered by GoldStar Trust. A properly executed direct trustee-to-trustee rollover is generally not taxable because the funds pass directly between qualified institutions. Eligibility depends on the employer plan, so consult the plan administrator, custodian, and a qualified tax professional.
Where will my metals be stored?
Non-IRA metals may be delivered or placed in segregated Brink’s storage. IRA metals must be stored at the approved depository selected through GoldStar Trust, such as Delaware Depository or another available facility. Home storage is not allowed under a conventional precious-metals IRA.
Final verdict
Should you choose Investment Rarities?
Investment Rarities is a reasonable choice for investors who want personal guidance purchasing physical silver or gold from a dealer with a history extending back to 1973. Its quote-based pricing, narrow public disclosures, and limited independent-review footprint mean customers should compare premiums, obtain all fees in writing, and verify custody terms before committing.
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission if you open an account through our links, at no extra cost to you. This can influence which companies we feature. We only cover providers we believe offer genuine value.
Not financial advice: Informational only. Precious-metals investing carries risk, including loss of principal. Consult a licensed advisor before investing.
